Is Roman Catholic Baptism Valid?

Written on 01/27/2025
Jim McCarthy

Over the past 10 years, I’ve been examined by 4 different presbyteries. These have been profoundly edifying experiences that have deepened my love for the brethren and biblical polity. While each presbytery’s exam had its own flavor, a unique blend mixed from past controversies within and denominational hot topics without, in each case I was asked, “Is Roman Catholic baptism valid?”

While this question is not of the same cardinal significance as others, it does reveal where one draws certain ecclesiastical and sacramental lines which will inevitably be tested in the trenches of pastoral ministry. So, this is a good and useful conversation for brothers to have in a spirit of unity, humility, and gentleness, as iron sharpens iron (Proverbs 27:7) for the blessing of God’s people and the glory of Christ. With those ends in mind, I offer four reasons I believe Roman Catholic baptism is invalid.

Read More...

The Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals is member supported and operates only by your faithful support . Thank you.